(If the €400 maintenance costs for the heat pump are eliminated).
Your calculation is mathematically fundamentally understandable; however, it is based on assumptions that inevitably drive the result in a certain direction.
For example, you assume that the heat pump only provides benefits during 30% of the annual mileage. In reality, it also operates at low positive temperatures, and especially during transitional periods, its efficiency advantage can be relevant.
Additionally, you overlook short trips. It is precisely there that the heating of the interior weighs particularly heavily in relation to the distance traveled. Contrary to widespread assumptions, a heat pump can indeed offer advantages.
This does not mean that the additional €990 cost will economically pay off for every driving profile. That will indeed be difficult. However, to derive from a deliberately conservatively chosen model calculation that a heat pump makes practically no sense seems a bit shortsighted to me.
And regarding the additional maintenance costs, I would first wait to see what specific maintenance requirements Volkswagen actually foresees for the ID. Cross. The dealer organization where I ordered our ID. Cross has confirmed in writing that maintenance costs for the heat pump will not be incurred after 4 years because a new, significantly more maintenance-friendly generation of heat pumps will be installed in all MEB+ platform derivatives
Why I ordered the heat pump: My first 3 BEVs came with the heat pump as standard. In all 3 vehicles, I managed to achieve significantly restrained consumption even in winter with my driving profiles on somewhat longer distances (the savings compared to pure PTC-only heating were explicitly shown to me in 2 of the 3 vehicles). I firmly believe that the heat pump will also be standard at VW in 3-4 years. BMW or Mercedes-Benz have not mentioned it for several years since it is standard. It is also installed in most current Chinese BEVs in the > €20,000 price range.
Therefore, I firmly assume that when reselling later in a few years, the installed heat pump will be appreciated or not penalized. I see the additional cost as an investment that benefits me and the next buyer. €1,000 more or less does not bother me, especially since a 20% discount will also be applied for this option. Friends and family members who recently ordered the sibling (Epiq) (a total of 3 vehicles) were also able to understand my reasoning and ordered the heat pumps. As for your comparison: In my opinion, it is flawed: Comparing a navigation system with an essential component of climate control does not really fit, as the integrated navigation can often be easily substituted with smartphone-based solutions (especially CarPlay, Android Auto)
These are my thoughts on the matter. Of course, everyone can take a different stance on this.